Comment

What Right Wing Extremists?

258
SixDegrees4/17/2009 6:45:40 pm PDT

re: #217 godfrey

I neither can, nor desire, to make any defense of burning heretics. Tudor England was a vicious place, and viciousness came from every side. I am deeply skeptical that St. Thomas More felt any “gleefulness” in any of the situations we all (I suspect) have no expertise in pontificating about.

What I object to is Charles’s insinuation that Thomas More is “known for” burning heretics. He is not. He is known for not capitulating to the tyranny of Henry VIII and not disowning his Catholic allegiance. It’s no secret I’m sympathetic to that, and I will make no apology for it.

Uh - that’s the “A Man For All Seasons” version. It left out the good bits.

Great movie, with lots to recommend it. But historically accurate, not so much, thanks to it’s omissions.