re: #361 klys (maker of Silmarils)
Someone brings me a rock and I tell them “that’s a rock.”
I promised my committee members I’d never actually try to pass myself off as a real geologist in that sense.
We have so many different kinds of really cool rocks here in Appalachia. I would never ever tell someone “that’s a rock”. Especially if it looks like a potato and it’s actually a geode.