re: #629 Nevergiveup

First of all I am only taking about HER decision in THIS case. Support her or don’t support her, that’s your right, but don’t confuse the discussion. It’s pretty clear she was sloppy and didn’t give this case it’s due consideration and she just got slapped down for it.

But that is the opposite of everything I’ve read about her ruling on this case for the last couple of months. Indeed everything I’d read on Ricci (that I respected) said she made the only decision she reasonably could, and all opinions predicted this SCOTUS decision.

So it doesn’t look ‘sloppy’, or like a ‘slap’. Sorry.